Understanding the Factors Behind Rising Trucking Insurance Costs in Canada

CTOA Industry Insight / Topic: Insurance, Safety, Policy

The Canadian Truck Operators Association (CTOA) represents trucking operators, fleet owners, brokers, and industry stakeholders across Canada. As discussions continue around rising insurance premiums in the trucking sector, it is important to examine the broader factors influencing transportation risks and insurance costs.

Recent industry conversations have highlighted accident severity and claims costs as key contributors to rising premiums. While these factors certainly play a role, the issue is far more complex and reflects significant economic, infrastructure, and transportation changes that have taken place over the past decade.

A balanced and comprehensive understanding of these factors is essential to developing policies that support both road safety and a resilient national supply chain.

Growth in Traffic and Road Congestion

Canada has experienced significant population growth and economic expansion over the past decade. As cities expand and economic activity increases, the number of vehicles on the road has also grown considerably.

Passenger vehicles, delivery vans, ride‑share vehicles, and commercial trucks have all increased. However, in many regions, road infrastructure has not expanded at the same pace.

Major freight corridors such as the Greater Toronto Area, Montreal, Vancouver, and Calgary are experiencing increasing congestion. Higher traffic density naturally increases the likelihood of road incidents for all road users, not just commercial trucks.

Understanding these broader transportation trends is important when evaluating safety risks and insurance claims across the sector.

Expanding Freight Demand and Supply Chain Growth

Over the past decade, Canada’s supply chain has undergone significant transformation. The rapid growth of e‑commerce, national distribution networks, and just‑in‑time delivery systems has increased demand for freight transportation.

Retailers, manufacturers, and logistics companies rely heavily on trucking to move goods efficiently across the country. As freight demand increases, trucks spend more time on the road and operate across increasingly complex logistics networks.

Trucking remains the backbone of Canada’s supply chain, ensuring that businesses and consumers receive essential goods every day.

Rising Equipment and Repair Costs

Another major factor influencing insurance claims is the rising cost of modern trucking equipment and repairs.

Today’s commercial trucks are significantly more advanced than they were a decade ago. They include complex electronics, safety sensors, and advanced driver‑assistance technologies. While these innovations improve safety and operational efficiency, they also increase the cost of repairs.

In addition, higher labour costs for technicians, global supply chain disruptions, and more expensive replacement parts have contributed to rising repair expenses.

As a result, even relatively minor collisions can generate significantly higher claim values than in the past.

Economic Pressures Across the Transportation Sector

The trucking industry has also experienced broader economic pressures in recent years. Rising fuel prices, higher financing costs for vehicles, inflation in parts and maintenance, and increased labour costs have all affected operating expenses.

These broader economic conditions influence the cost of claims and the financial models used within the insurance sector.

Understanding these pressures helps provide a more complete picture of the challenges faced by both trucking operators and insurers.

Road Safety Is a Shared Responsibility

Road safety is influenced by many factors across the entire transportation ecosystem. Traffic congestion, infrastructure design, driver behaviour across all vehicle types, weather conditions, and road conditions can all contribute to collisions.

For this reason, improving road safety requires a system‑wide approach that involves government, transportation planners, insurers, and industry stakeholders.

Focusing on the broader transportation environment helps ensure that policies address the root causes of safety risks rather than attributing responsibility to a single segment of the industry.

Technology and Safety Improvements

The trucking industry has made significant investments in technology to improve safety and reduce operational risks.

Many fleets are adopting tools such as:

• telematics systems
• dash cameras
• driver monitoring technologies
• advanced safety management programs

These technologies help companies better understand driving behaviour, identify safety risks early, and strengthen training programs for drivers. Over time, these investments can contribute to safer operations and improved risk management across the industry.

The Importance of Collaboration

Rising insurance costs affect the entire supply chain, including trucking companies, insurers, retailers, manufacturers, and consumers.

The Canadian Truck Operators Association (CTOA) believes that addressing these challenges requires constructive collaboration between government, insurers, and industry stakeholders.

Policy discussions should focus on:

• improving transportation infrastructure
• strengthening safety programs and driver training
• addressing insurance fraud and cargo theft
• supporting the adoption of safety technologies

• ensuring transparency and stability in insurance markets

A collaborative approach will help ensure that policies support both road safety and a stable, efficient supply chain.

Key Industry Trends Influencing Insurance Costs

Several long‑term transportation trends help explain the changing insurance environment:

• Vehicle growth: Canada’s total registered vehicles increased from roughly 23 million in 2013 to over 26 million in 2022 (Statistics Canada).
• Urban congestion: Drivers in major freight corridors such as the Greater Toronto Area lose over 100 hours annually due to traffic congestion.

• Rising truck values: A modern heavy‑duty commercial truck can now cost $200,000–$250,000, significantly higher than a decade ago.

These broader transportation trends illustrate why insurance risk and claim costs must be viewed within the context of a growing and increasingly complex transportation network.    (Sources: Statistics Canada, transportation studies, and industry market data.)

Supporting a Strong and Sustainable Trucking Industry

Trucking remains essential to Canada’s economy. From food and consumer goods to industrial materials and medical supplies, most products rely on trucking at some point in their journey.

Ensuring the long‑term sustainability of the trucking sector is therefore critical for the stability of Canada’s supply chain.

By examining the full range of factors influencing insurance costs and working together across sectors, policymakers and industry leaders can develop balanced solutions that support both economic growth and safer roads for all Canadians.

Canadian Truck Operators Association (CTOA)
Supporting trucking operators and strengthening Canada’s supply chain.